18 August 2020

Pre-existing immune-resistant cancer cells identified in melanoma

New research in scientific journal Nature Communications

Elize Brolsma

Researchers at the Netherlands Cancer Institute, led by Oncode Investigator Daniel Peeper with Julia Boshuizen as first author, have discovered a cluster of tumor cells that are refractory to immunotherapy and that exists even prior to treatment. This finding, which was published in the scientific journal Nature Communications, may lead to new therapies that eliminate cancer more effectively.

The research group focused on melanoma, an aggressive form of skin cancer. The perspective of patients with late stage melanoma has improved in recent years, thanks to new precision therapies that target either the tumor cells themselves or the immune cells that attack the cancer. The latter approach, called immunotherapy, serves to enhance tumor killing by T cells, a specialized group of immune cells. An increasing group of patients experiences durable clinical benefit from immunotherapy. However, many tumors display some form of resistance.

Pre-existing T cell-resistance
Resistance to immunotherapy can occur during treatment but can also manifest upfront. PhD student and clinician Julia Boshuizen and her colleagues in Peeper’s laboratory wondered whether melanoma cells that show resistance to cytotoxic T cells can be found in patients prior to treatment.

To identify such cells, she first exposed cultured melanoma cells from patients to T cells, which killed most of the tumor cells as expected. However, a few melanoma cells survived the treatment, as is often also the case in patients. After repeating this cycle several times, Boshuizen uncovered a peculiar group of surviving tumor cells. Not only were they now fully resistant to T cells, but they also expressed high amounts of a protein located at their cell surface, Nerve Growth Factor Receptor (NGFR). NGFR is a protein that is important for survival of neuronal cells during the development of an organism, but it seems to be ‘hijacked’ by these melanoma cells for the sake of their survival.

Then, the researchers searched for NGFR-positive cells in patients’ melanomas and discovered that they frequently contain such cells, even before any treatment. Thus, tumors may contain cells that are resistant to immunotherapy before they are actually treated. Furthermore, parts of melanomas that showed high NGFR expression were often much less infiltrated with T cells than regions with low NGFR.

Multi-therapy resistance
Another surprise came when Boshuizen tested the sensitivity of these T cell-refractory melanoma cells to other therapies that are being used in the clinic. She found that NGFR-expressing melanoma cells were also resistant to two precision medicines that serve to eliminate the tumor, BRAF and MEK inhibitor. The cells were more refractory to chemotherapy and irradiation, too. These results suggest that this particular group of melanoma cells is resistant to both tumor and immunotherapies and hence, should be eliminated.

Reverting resistance
Therefore, the investigators examined next what the role of NGFR was in T cell-resistance, hoping that it was not just a biomarker but actually contributed to the behavior of these tumor cells. When they used drugs to suppress the expression of NGFR, they noted that, indeed, cultured melanoma cells were re-sensitized to T cells. Melanoma-bearing mice, too, survived longer when NGFR was inhibited during immunotherapy.

Clinical translation
The investigators conclude that NGFR may be an attractive therapeutic target to be used in combination with immunotherapy. Peeper: “We are excited about this finding and aim to translate it to the clinic. However, there are no NGFR precision medicines available yet. An appealing alternative is to use the cell membrane localization of NGFR to target it with an antibody, a type of approach that is successfully exploited for immunotherapy. A key question is whether this would cause undesired side effects on normal cells that also express NGFR, which we want to investigate next”.

This work was funded by the European Research Council, the Dutch Cancer Society and Oncode Institute.

Other News

Oncode Icons Square 22
First Oncode Clinical Proof of Concept (CPoC) project now finalized
We are happy to announce that our first Oncode CPoC study - a collaboration between Oncode Investigator Jean Paul Medema (Amsterdam UMC) and clinician Henk Verheul (Radboud UMC) titled Pulsatile high dose Sunitinib as a specific drug for (a subset of) metastatic mesenchymal CRCs - is now finalized.
Oncode Icons Square research strategy copy
New CPoC grant awarded: researchers and clinicians team up for study on gastroenteropancreatic neuroendocrine tumors (GEPNETs)
Oncode Institute keeps investing in bringing insights from basic science into clinical practice. With the 12th grant awarded within the CPoC programme, Oncode Investigator Roland Kanaar together with Oncode researcher Julie Nonnekens (both Erasmus MC) will team up with a group of clinicians, a physicist and pharmacist for a project focused on gastroenteropancreatic neuroendocrine tumors (GEPNETs).
Oncode about icon copy 4
Oncode Facilities & Technologies will add value to your research
The goal of Oncode Institute is to translate the results of ground-breaking fundamental research into the clinic faster, in order to improve the chances of cancer patients. Investing in new technologies and facilities - which are available to all Oncode researchers - is one of the ways that Oncode wants to contribute to breakthroughs in cancer research. In this interview Jacqueline Staring, Programme Manager at Oncode Institute, discusses the facilities and technologies that are available for the Oncode research community and how they will support and accelerate oncology research.


Elize is part of Oncode’s communication team. She has over 10 years of experience in the com-munication industry, both for commercial and non-profit organisations. After obtaining her bache-lor and master degree in communication at Utrecht University, Elize worked as a communication professional at a research institute, PR agency, law firm and internet company. She has a strong focus on external communications and Public Relations. At Oncode - together with her colleagues - Elize produces the monthly newsletters for Oncode Investigators & Researchers and the Oncode digital magazine. She publishes content for the Oncode website and is responsible for all social media channels. She enjoys discussing science with researchers and support them in their outreach.